Security Barriers or Security Gates: Which is Right for You?

When it comes to securing your vacant property, construction site, or event, one pivotal decision you’ll need to make will be whether to choose security barriers or gates. The choices you make in this regard can dramatically affect safety, efficiency, and overall quality.
At Maltaward, we understand that making the right choices pertaining to your premises safety will all hinge on your specific goals, security requirements and budget. While some may argue that money should be no object when it comes to safety, these factors influence what is feasible and affordable.
This guide is here to help you determine whether security gates or barriers will be best suited to you.
Security Barriers
Physical security barriers serve as the first line of defence in controlling access while maintaining efficient traffic flow. These durable and resilient products are designed to manage vehicle and pedestrian movement in and out of your premises, preventing unauthorised access to restricted areas.
Types of Security Barriers
Concrete barriers
Our MASS safety barriers provide robust security for construction sites, events, and roadworks. These heavy-duty units offer exceptional protection against vehicle intrusion and can be rapidly deployed or moved with the help of on-site machinery.
Integrated barrier systems
For enhanced security, MANTA barriers combine galvanised steel blocks with integrated fencing, creating a comprehensive security solution that addresses both vehicle and pedestrian safety issues.
Temporary metal fencing
HERAS and crowd steel fencing options provide flexible security for short-term projects, events, or areas requiring frequent access point changes.
Semi-permanent barriers
TVCB (Temporary Vertical Concrete Barrier) fencing integrates precast concrete blocks with mesh panels, offering a stable yet adaptable security perimeter.
Benefits of Barriers
- Barriers can be quickly repositioned as your security needs evolve, making them ideal for dynamic environments like construction sites or temporary events.
- For projects with changing security requirements or limited budgets, barriers typically require a lower upfront investment compared to gates.
- Security perimeters can be easily moved using modular barrier systems that fit most site configurations, whatever their complexity.
Security Gates
Security gates provide a complete access control solution, creating definitive entry and exit points. These products are designed to thoroughly regulate who can enter a property or area, with Maltaward’s TVCB gate system being a flexible and widely used solution.
Types of Gates
Swing gates
Traditional gates that pivot on hinges, suitable for locations with adequate space for the gate’s arc.
Sliding gates
Ideal for areas with limited space, as they move parallel to the fence line.
Cantilever gates
Self-supporting sliding gates that don’t require a ground track, excellent for uneven terrain.
Bi-folding gates
Space-saving design that folds as it opens, offering a compromise between swing and sliding configurations.
Benefits of Gates
- Gates provide complete closure of access points, creating a definitive boundary that controls all entry and exit.
- Modern security gates can incorporate access control systems, surveillance, and automation features for enhanced protection.
- A well-designed gate system projects an image of professionalism and security consciousness to visitors and clients.
- Though typically more expensive initially, gates often offer better long-term value for permanent locations.
How to Decide Between Gates and Barriers
Temporary or permanent?
For short-term projects, temporary barriers like HERAS fencing or MASS barriers prove more cost-effective. That said, for permanent installations, palisade fencing or security gates offer long-lasting protection.
Traffic volume
High-traffic environments may benefit from barriers that facilitate controlled flow, while lower-traffic, high-security areas might be better suited to gates. Consider whether perimeters will need to be altered in the long run.
Risk assessment
The nature of threats you’re protecting against should guide your choice. Vehicle threats might require heavy-duty concrete Jersey barriers, while preventing unauthorised personnel access might call for integrated systems like MANTA barriers with fencing.
Many sites benefit from a combination of barriers and gates. For example:
- Concrete MASS barriers protecting the perimeter with gated access points
- TVCB fencing surrounding a site with controlled gate entry systems
- Palisade fencing establishing a permanent boundary with movable and temporary HERAS fencing erected once inside
Options That Extend Further Than Physical Security
Remember that physical security works best as part of a comprehensive strategy. Consider enhancing your barriers or gates with:
Best Security Gates, Barriers and Products to Buy or Hire
Every site presents unique security challenges. At Maltaward, our team specialises in assessing your specific requirements and recommending the optimal mix of barriers, gates, and complementary security measures to protect your assets, personnel, and operations.
Contact our specialists today for a personalised security assessment and recommendations tailored to your needs.